Feb
09

Whyville: If Only… (or, Thoughts on Censorship)

Filed Under (Discussion Topics, Parent Ideas, Resources) by Laura Smith on 09-02-2009 and tagged , ,

I tried to get a website unblocked through the state, but it was denied because of the chat feature.  This was one of the main reasons that I wanted to have access to the site!  The site is called Whyville.  The link I provided was to the Wikipedia entry, as anyone in Tennessee would not be able to actually view the site at all. The entry can provide all the information about this science-driven interactive world.

One article about Whyville reported:

In Texas, Whyville recently received grants totaling $440,000 from the Texas Workforce Commission to build Whyville Biotech and Whyville Advanced Manufacturing Center.

The site’s designers created Whyville Biotech to teach kids how to develop vaccines against WhyPox, a flu-like epidemic that erupts each year. WhyPox causes kids’ avatars — their virtual characters — to break out with red spots on their faces. Last fall, during real-world flu season, the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention virtually vaccinated 134,000 kids in Whyville.

Through the Texas grant, kids also will learn about drug design and discovery, as well as new techniques in computational biology, Bower said.

Eventually, Whyville citizens will build biotechnology companies in Whyville, Bower said.

“From a work-force standpoint, this is huge,” he said. “We have a ‘cool’ factor, but we’re also doing something very useful for these industries.”

Whyville features all kinds of simulations of real-world events. Residents recently dealt with Tropical Storm Alice and are learning about the effects of global warming. The J. Paul Getty Museum of Los Angeles teaches kids about great works of art at its Whyville gallery.

But science is the main focus.

“You cannot learn science through textbooks,” Bower told a group of Texas educators at a conference in San Antonio last month. “It kills science.”

Kids go to Whyville to socialize, but they also participate in fun activities from science quizzes to writing articles for the Whyville Times, the town newspaper, Bower said.

“It’s a big, big world, and lots of things are going on,” said Yasmin Kafai, associate professor of education at the University of California at Los Angeles. She received a grant from the National Science Foundation to study Whyville.  Read more.

I understand the message I received from the Tennessee K12 Cooperative.  It has a chat feature.  Yes, I understand that, but there is something called moderation.  Secondly, how in the world are we going to teach students to be good digital citizens if we block every website that allows them to actually apply what we’ve taught them?

Because so many students are using technology as it is part of almost every aspect of their lives, the role of technology in education should be to teach them digital citizenship, how to use technology appropriately, how to problem solve issues, and how to learn via digital sources.  Our administrators need to encourage experimentation from teachers, allow types of technology that they are blocking, such as instant messaging programs, text messaging, blogging, chat rooms, message boards, and other means of digital communication.  We cannot expect students to learn how to use these sorts of technology appropriately without guidance, therefore we need to incorporate their use into learning in the classroom and teach digital citizenship while students are actually getting practical application.  The real life classroom must also become a digital community.

I’m going to apply for an authorized override, and explore the site some more.  If I really find value in it, I think I’m going to challenge this whole blocked business.

To any parents reading, go and check out the site for yourself.  Read the online safety procedures and recommendations that Whyville provides, and see if you can’t at least provide this engaging world of science for your own child at home.

Create a free edublog to get your own comment avatar (and more!)

5 Responses to “Whyville: If Only… (or, Thoughts on Censorship)”

  1.   Cindy Says:

    Great article, Laura! I think you are absolutely right.

  2.   Tech Tools - All About Tech Integration » Article on Censorship Says:

    [...] you have a minute, read this important and insightful article by Laura Smith.  I think she is absolutely right in her assessment of this issue.  Should students be held to [...]

  3.   Cindy Says:

    I linked to your article on my blog today.

  4.   Jim Bower Says:

    Hi everyone, I am actually Jim Bower, founder of Whyville (quoted above) — and needless to say, I couldn’t agree more.

    two things: 1) I can link you to teachers and school administrators who have won this fight for Whyville and can provide your administrators real world proof of the points you are making.

    2) I am happy to send you a 19 page white paper on how moderation and community control works in Whyville. The site is increasingly receiving independent awards by parenting groups for safety.

    kids will always be kids — however, I couldn’t agree more, wouldn’t you rather have them engaged in social media in the context of schools and professional guidance, than out there on their own – which, by the way, they are. :-)

    let me know how I can help.

    jim@numedeon.com

  5.   Linda Eller Says:

    I agree completely and would be glad to help you with pursuing the unblocked site permission.
    As you stated in your article, “The real life classroom must also become a digital community.”- Laura Smith, 2009

    You are so right and have the foresight and vision to look forward with classroom practice.

Leave a Reply

*
To prove you're a person (not a spam script), type the security word shown in the picture.
Anti-Spam Image